“Freemason Zionist Gestapo” (?!) or Note on re-posting

The previous post, “Introducing Ethnic Cleansing” has been generously re-posted by a number of activist websites, including by Rela Mazali on The Only Democracy and Adam Horowtiz on Mondoweiss. The admins for all these sites asked permission, which was happily granted. However, I learned today from a pingback the piece was also re-reposted from Mazali’s website, without notice to either of us, on a strange little website known as “Shoah: The Palestinian Holocaust.” The admin or admins also took trouble to inject the strange term “Zio=nazi” into the article’s already strong-worded title.

Screenshot taken at 4:30pm Israeli time

Here’s what I wrote to the administrators, so far to no avail:

As author of the article you reposted without permission, I kindly ask you to remove it forthwith. The “Zio=nazi” term, which you had the audacity to insert into my headline, is inaccurate, counterproductive, and deeply offensive to many people who legitimately support some form of Jewish Israeli self-determination, but strongly and actively oppose violation of Palestinian rights. Furthermore, I notice your website pollutes the Palestinian struggle and legitimate criticism of Israeli policies with repugnant terms from the classical anti-Semitic vocabulary, such as “freemasonry.”* I would not want to be associated with such a site in any way. Thanks.”

*The (inane) link between Freemasonry, Judaism and New World Order ramblings is a tell-tale sign of anti-Semitism in its crudest form; so much so that Russian anti-Semites and pogromists profusely used the term “judomasons” (жидомасоны).

The “SHOAH” website, which has no information on who or what is behind it, appears to be mainly an aggregator of any and all negative information about Israel, with headlines carefully amended to appear as moronic and anti-Semitic as possible. It also has the nerve to note in its footer that “© 2010 SHOAH. All Rights Reserved,” which is news to me and most probably to all other authors being similarly libelled by association.

I’ve run a couple of inquiries on who might be operating this exercise in moral, intellectual and political embarrassment, but no one seems to be in the know. An activist friend similarly appalled suggested even it was a black op by some ultra-Right group or person trying to prove all critics of Israel are anti-Semites. While this is a possbility, I think the more honest and responsible thing is to assume this is the work of one of those fellow-travellers who seem to exist solely to prove the Hasbara’s worst slanders: Anti-Zionist anti-Semites, or anti-Semites who also happen to be anti-Zionist.

The subject of choosing allies on the left deserved an entirely separate post, but meanwhile, I wanted to ask for your help: Do you know who owns this website, or who operates it? Since my initial request went unheeded, I’m now aiming to expose whoever it is – and, unless they remove the post and apologize, I’m beginning to be pretty curious to explore legal avenues. Comment below or email me (dimis DOT notes AT gmail DOT com) if you happen to have any clues.

5 Comments

Filed under Blog

5 responses to ““Freemason Zionist Gestapo” (?!) or Note on re-posting

  1. Shay

    While the domain is registered in the UK, the site itself is hosted by an American ISP, justhost.com, operating from Chicago.

    If you’d simply like to get the content removed, you can bring a DMCA complaint with them, or ask them to enforce their terms of service which prohibits sites that infringe on another’s copyright, or distributing hate speech.

  2. Pingback: Introducing Ethnic Cleansing « Dimi’s notes

  3. The person who runs it is I believe named Sami Ibrahim, who actually e-mailed me once when I was in Gaza to interview me. I don’t know anything else about him, he re-posts all my stuff and doesn’t link back to my blog, either. I stopped caring. It is dumb and kind of ugly to change titles like that, but in my opinion there are more dangerous people within the movement that I am quite a bit more worried about that someone like him. I am not sure that he is an anti-Semite, actually, there are people who use this (self-defeating) discourse of “Zion-Nazis” and “AshkeNazi” who are not anti-Semitic, just dumb or indulgent or angry or ignorant or some combination thereof, or who just see it used and it makes sense to them and they use it unthinkingly. Good luck trying to track this person down.

    -max

  4. Dimi

    Hey Max,

    Thanks for that info. What raised the anti-Semitism flag for me wasn’t the Nazi comparison (which is mostly self-defeating in a myriad ways), but the Freemason one. By the way – I notice you quote me on the blog as my fellow +972 blogger Didi Remez :)

    Thanks again,

    Dimi

  5. If you have the time & are willing to take the trouble (I probably wouldn’t) you can go to the host’s website & look up their terms for filing a DMCA complaint with them. The law has specific terms which the complaint should include so best to use the form or format the host offers.

    As soon as you file it they by law are required to take it down.

    I’ve done this when David Duke republished one of my post w/o permission. He was forced to take it down. But he just republished another one after that. So what are you going to do?

    What I do is post under “terms of use” conditions under which my posts may be republished. At least, in that case you’re letting anyone who’s decent enough to care know you want them to inform you if they’ve republished yr work.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s